- Generation 2004 - https://generation2004.eu/ -

The Reality Behind Commission Performance Plans: Lessons from a Court Judgment

The General Court has di [1]smissed the action in Case T-622/24 [2], concerning an unsatisfactory appraisal report and the support plan put in place for a Commission official. 

Although the applicant did not succeed, the judgment raises important questions for staff: What makes a support plan meaningful? How much time must an official be given to improve? And what happens when a manager has more than one role in the appraisal process? 

Generation 2004 supported the applicant in pursuing these proceedings because the issues raised went beyond an individual appraisal dispute. The case concerns safeguards that matter to all Commission staff: fair appraisal procedures, meaningful support plans and the impartiality of those involved in assessing performance. By supporting the case, Generation 2004 sought to contribute to greater clarity on these important issues. 

  1. A support plan must be meaningful

The Court examined whether the Commission had complied with its rules on support plans. It accepted that the plan had provided sufficient time and monitoring in the circumstances of this case. It also found that the plan contained the required objectives, timeline, follow-up arrangements, and support measures. 

Importantly, the Court did not consider the fact that the overall performance remained unsatisfactory to be proof that the support plan itself had been inadequate. 

What this means for staff: A support plan should not be treated as a mere administrative exercise. Its objectives, support measures, monitoring arrangements and assessment criteria matter. Staff should keep records of the support offered, feedback received and progress made. 

  1. The assessment must address the objectives – and the efforts made

The Court found that the 2022 appraisal report had addressed the objectives of the support plan, either expressly or implicitly. It considered that the report’s comments on the applicant’s work covered several of those objectives. 

This is an important aspect of the judgment. Article 5(6) requires the reporting officer to assess the official’s efforts to achieve the support-plan objectives in the following appraisal report. 

A point worth watching: There may be a legal question as to whether assessing shortcomings in work is necessarily the same as assessing the efforts made to achieve the objectives. This distinction could be relevant when considering a possible appeal. 

  1. The question of impartiality was not decided on its merits

The applicant argued that the same manager had contributed to the appraisal and acted as countersigning officer. The Court rejected this argument as inadmissible because it had not been raised in the prior administrative complaint. 

This is an important distinction: the Court did not rule that the dual role was compatible with the principle of objective impartiality. It did not examine the substance of that argument. 

Practical lesson: Potential procedural and impartiality concerns should be raised clearly and at the appropriate stage of the administrative procedure. Waiting until proceedings before the Court may be too late. 

  1. What about an appeal?

An appeal is possible, but it is not a second examination of the facts. The Court of Justice would examine points of law, not simply reassess the applicant’s performance or replace the General Court’s evaluation with its own. 

One issue that may merit closer examination is the interpretation of Article 5(6): did the appraisal genuinely assess the applicant’s efforts to achieve the support-plan objectives, or did it mainly assess the results and shortcomings of his work? 

The procedural ruling on impartiality may also be worth examining, although the fact that the argument was not raised in the administrative complaint presents a significant obstacle. 

What happens next? 

Generation 2004 will now undertake a further in-depth analysis of the judgment, examining its legal reasoning and the possible grounds for appeal. On that basis, we will assess whether an appeal before the Court of Justice is justified and in the interests of the staff concerned. No decision on whether to appeal has yet been taken. We will keep our members informed of the outcome of this assessment and of any further developments. 

 Further reading: What the judgment says in more detail 

💡 What did the Court examine when assessing the support plan?

Article 5 of the Commission Decision of 4 October 2019 sets out the requirements for support plans. The Court examined several aspects of the plan put in place for the applicant. 

Was the applicant given enough time to improve? 

The support plan was put in place in October 2022 and ran until 31 December 2022. The applicant therefore had approximately two and a half months to demonstrate progress. 

The Court considered this period sufficient in the circumstances, taking into account the nature of the shortcomings identified. It did not establish a general minimum duration for support plans. Rather, it assessed the period in the context of this particular case. 

Was the monitoring appropriate? 

The applicant was required to provide weekly reports setting out the activities carried out during the previous week and the tasks planned for the following week. The Court did not consider this reporting requirement unreasonable. It noted that the reports were intended to give management a continuous overview of the applicant’s activities and did not require a response. 

The Court also took into account the monthly reports prepared by the hierarchy in October, November, and December 2022, as well as the monitoring meetings in which the applicant participated. 

Were the objectives sufficiently clear and specific? 

The Court found that the plan included objectives covering the areas of efficiency, ability and conduct. These included: 

  • contributing to three team communication projects; 
  • improving the quality of work and responses to citizens on EU policies; 
  • improving the use of IT tools; 
  • improving written and oral English; 
  • ensuring availability during working hours. 

The plan also set a timetable, provided for periodic follow-up and training, and identified criteria for assessing progress. These included the management, quality and timeliness of replies to citizens, the ability to use IT tools independently and efficiently, knowledge of procedures and presence in the office. 

The Court also considered that the role of the support person had been sufficiently defined. It included providing advice, holding informal meetings, reviewing difficulties and opportunities, and offering guidance on career mobility when requested. 

Did the fact that the plan did not lead to a satisfactory appraisal prove that it was inadequate? 

No. The Court made clear that an unsatisfactory outcome following a support plan does not, in itself, demonstrate that the plan was inadequate or that the Commission had failed to comply with its obligations. 

Did the Commission have to continue the support plan in 2023? 

The applicant also criticised the fact that the support plan had not been continued in 2023. The Court considered this argument ineffective (inopérant): the case concerned the legality of the 2022 appraisal report, and the applicant’s performance in 2023 could not affect the legality of an assessment relating to 2022. 

Why this matters 

The judgment confirms that the Court will examine the practical arrangements of a support plan: its duration, objectives, monitoring, feedback and support measures. However, the Court assessed the arrangements in this particular case and did not lay down a universal model or minimum duration. 

For staff, the practical lesson is to ask for clear and measurable objectives, a realistic timetable, appropriate training and support, regular feedback and a transparent assessment of progress. It is equally important to keep written records of the support provided and of the efforts made to meet each objective. 

💡How did the Court assess compliance with Article 5(6)?

Article 5(6) requires the reporting officer to assess the official’s efforts to attain the objectives set out in the support plan in the following appraisal report. 

The Court considered that the 2022 appraisal report addressed those objectives, either expressly or implicitly. It noted, for example, that the report expressly stated that the communication-style objective had not been met. 

Other objectives were considered to have been addressed through the report’s comments on the applicant’s work for the outreach team, the virtual stand, the toolkit and replies to citizens. The Court also referred to the level of monitoring and correction required from the hierarchy. 

This reasoning may be particularly relevant to any appeal. A possible legal question is whether an assessment of shortcomings and results necessarily amounts to an assessment of the official’s efforts to achieve the objectives. The distinction between effort and outcome deserves attention. 

💡 Why did the Court not examine the impartiality argument? 

The applicant argued that the same manager had contributed to the appraisal and acted as countersigning officer. However, this argument had not been raised in the administrative complaint. 

The Court applied the rule of correspondence between the administrative complaint and the subsequent court action. Since the dual-role argument was not sufficiently connected to the arguments raised in the complaint, the Court considered it inadmissible. 

The Court did examine a separate question: whether the manager had the hierarchical authority to countersign the report. It concluded that the manager was the direct hierarchical superior of the reporting officer and was entitled to countersign under the applicable rules. 

It is therefore important not to interpret the judgment as a ruling that the dual role complied with the principle of objective impartiality. The Court did not decide that substantive question. 

💡 What are the limits of an appeal? 

An appeal to the Court of Justice is limited to points of law. It is not a second examination of the facts or of the applicant’s performance. 

An appeal must identify specific errors of law in the General Court’s judgment. It cannot simply repeat arguments already made or ask the Court of Justice to reassess the evidence. 

Potential issues worth examining include: 

  • whether the General Court correctly interpreted the obligation under Article 5(6) to assess the official’s efforts to achieve the support-plan objectives; 
  • whether the Court applied the correct legal standard when assessing the adequacy of the reasoning in the appraisal report; 
  • whether the Court correctly applied the rule of correspondence when finding the impartiality argument inadmissible. 

The last point faces a significant procedural obstacle because the dual-role argument was not included in the administrative complaint. 

The deadline for an appeal is generally two months from notification of the judgment. The actual notification date must therefore be established before calculating the deadline.