The Commission’s approach to office presence is once again raising serious concern among staff. What is being presented as a matter of “coherence” and “organisational need” is, in practice, being experienced by many colleagues as a rigid and unnecessary tightening of control over how they work. Our members reached out already to ask for support in the witches’ hunt initiated by the new compliance indicators released by DG HR in September (a compliance flag for the Time Management Dashboard for the HR Correspondents, and a compliance occurrence rate for line managers).
Article 9 of the Decision on Working Time and Hybrid Working sets a minimum office presence of 40% of the weekly working time (16 hours per week in the office out of the 40 hours of weekly working). This means that even if a staff member comes to the office two days, they may still fall short of the requirement in case they have not actually worked 8 hours in each of those days, excluding lunch. In practice, this creates situations where staff who believe they are respecting the rules may nevertheless be recorded as non-compliant.
The new compliance indicators According to a recent Flash-note published by DG HR, more than 90% of staff have been fully compliant in 2026 with the office presence rule. Nevertheless, DG HR identified a need to better allow HR Correspondents and line managers to monitor the rules on office presence. DG HR therefore introduced three new indicators in the September release of the Time Management and Working Conditions dashboard:
- Compliance flag – a Yes/No indicator showing whether a staff member’s weekly working pattern complies with the 40% office presence threshold.
- Compliance metric – calculated based on a formula that looks at the proportion of the SYSPER declared time in the office, including justified absences from the office such as recuperation, missions, telework from abroad, sick leave or bank holidays, over the standard 40 hours of weekly working; if this is 40% or above, the compliance flag is marked “Yes”. If it falls below 40%, the flag is marked “No”. The compliance metric seems open, since it considers presence in the office also the justified absences, but what matters is trust and results, not ticking timesheets.
- Compliance occurrence rate – an indicator measuring the percentage of compliance with the Decision over a given period of time.
In a document from the intranet called Compliance Indicators Case Scenarios, which has not been properly advertised, staff can find several scenarios to understand their personal situation. More explanations can be found also here FAQ-Details behind Compliance Flag-Rate.pdf.
Why this matters for staff
For staff, these new indicators may be seen as adding a further layer of monitoring, with possible implications for how compliance is assessed by management.
Let us be clear: staff have delivered. They have continued to produce results under difficult circumstances for many years, adapted to new ways of working, to open Offices and hot desking, and have shown professionalism and commitment throughout all these changes in the working conditions. Hybrid working has not weakened the institution. On the contrary, it has demonstrated that flexibility and performance can go hand in hand. The attempt to row back from this reality is not only disappointing – it risks being counterproductive, adding another layer to the reasons for staff dissatisfaction, stress and disengagement.
The insistence on stricter office presence rules sends the wrong message. It suggests that presenteeism is being valued over output, and that trust is being replaced with surveillance. This is not a modern personnel policy; it is a step backwards. Many colleagues are asking the same basic questions: what problem is this solving? Where is the evidence that office presence improves efficiency, cooperation or service delivery, and why are staff being asked to absorb the practical burden of top-down decisions that do not reflect the diversity of jobs, family situations, commuting realities and workplace constraints across the institution?
A one-size-fits-all approach is neither fair nor effective
Different services have different operational needs. Different roles require different forms of collaboration. Different staff face very different daily realities. Any serious policy on presence and teleworking must start from these facts, not ignore them.
There is also a wider issue of credibility. The Commission cannot speak publicly about modern employment practices, work-life balance, inclusion and sustainability, while internally imposing measures that may be seen as inflexible, poorly justified and disconnected from reality. For colleagues with long commutes, caring or parenting responsibilities, health considerations or accessibility needs, these rules are not abstract management choices, having direct consequences on their daily life.
Staff are entitled to expect better
Staff are entitled to clear reasoning, meaningful consultation and policies based on evidence rather than ticking the box exercises. They are entitled to management that treats them as professionals, not as individuals whose commitment must be demonstrated by physical presence for its own sake. What about situations when staff is working from other Commission buildings because of meetings they chair or contribute to? What about cases in which the staff faces a mild respiratory virus but still work an entire week from home. Are they supposed to spread that in the entire open space building? How are such situations captured in the time management dashboards?
Generation 2004 therefore calls that any rules on office presence are proportionate, transparent and adapted to real operational needs. The administration must leave room for flexibility at local level, ensure equal treatment across services, and fully respect staff wellbeing. What is needed now is not more rigidity, but more trust: not imposed uniformity, but intelligent flexibility; not decisions handed down without proper dialogue, but genuine social conversation with staff representatives.