Healthcare in Italy: Court Rejects Discrimination Against JSIS Affiliates

Problem unresolved for decades 

A high number of Commission Ispra-based staff is not – and despite their best efforts is unable to become – a holder of the national health insurance card, the tessera sanitaria. Many colleagues and their families have remained locked out of the Italian National Health Service –Servizio Sanitario Nazionale (SSN), unable to register with a medico di base (General Practitioner) or access vaccination for decades, even before the latest rounds of restrictions and denials of access. Every day and in particular when a major medical emergency happen, colleagues in Italy cannot easily use standard public networks and instead face complexities and friction. 

Wind of change 

The Ordinary Court of Bologna recently issued an important judgment concerning access to the SSN for a retired EU staff member residing in Italy and covered by the JSIS. The Court held that the person concerned has the right to compulsory and free registration with the SSN. 

The former colleague argued that, without SSN registration, he could not effectively access a number of healthcare services available through the Italian public system, including access to a general practitioner, certain hospital-only medicines, recognition of chronic conditions, disability-related procedures, and the personal health file access.  

The Court confirmed that the dispute concerned the protection of a fundamental individual right, namely the right to health, and therefore fell within the jurisdiction of the ordinary court rather than administrative tribunals. 

Crucially, the Court also found that JSIS is not equivalent to the SSN. According to the judgment, JSIS provides a system of reimbursement of medical costs, but it does not itself provide healthcare services or medicines directly. By contrast, the SSN is a broader public healthcare system aimed at protecting health universally and directly through structures and services. 

The Court therefore concluded that denying free SSN registration to a resident in Italy solely because he is a former EU employee covered by JSIS would amount to unjustified unequal treatment and would be contrary to the constitutional principles of equality and protection of health. This principle directly extends to active EU officials in Italy who face the same barriers, both Italian and non-Italian citizens. This is a very encouraging step in the right direction and a strong signal for the Italian government and for the European Commission to finalise the long-awaited agreement providing a tessera sanitaria to all EU staff working in Italy. 

Our position 

Generation 2004 recognises the urgency of the situation and relentlessly works to achieve non-discriminatory access to health care for all the statutory staff, irrespective of their nationality. 

Besides continuously cooperating with other trade unions and engaging with the administration to achieve a solution granting access to all, Generation 2004 also supported a collective legal action of a number of active and retired colleagues of multiple nationalities. They are being represented by Antonio De Angelis – the same attorney who secured the Bologna judgement – to obtain clarity on constitutional rights and access to the tessera sanitaria. 

Generation 2004 urges the Commission to swiftly finalise the negotiations with the Italian authorities to secure a tessera sanitaria for all active and retired EU staff living in Italy.  Ispra is Commission’s third largest site and the progress in Italy would help the most colleagues. It should also pave the way for equal access to healthcare across all EU countries, including the Netherlands and Sweden, where JSIS members face problems.  

The status quo is not acceptable and we cannot wait forever – a solution for all needs to be implemented, fast!  

Please provide us with your comments  

Do you want to become a member? 

 

 

Leave a Reply